2051 Dauphin Street, Mobile, Alabama 36606
Law Office of J. Allan Brown
Free Consultation

Why You Shouldn’t Give an Insurance Adjuster Your Health History

Why You Shouldn't Give an Insurance Adjuster Your Health History

Have you ever found yourself in a situation where an insurance adjuster is asking for your complete health history? It’s a common scenario that many people face when dealing with insurance claims, especially in personal injury cases. Sharing your health history with an insurance adjuster can compromise your medical privacy and potentially reduce your compensation, as they may use pre-existing conditions to downplay the severity of your injuries. Before sharing any information, it’s crucial to understand your rights under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). 

Understanding the Role of Insurance Adjusters     

Before we dive into the risks of sharing your health history, let’s take a moment to understand who insurance adjusters are and what motivates them. 

Insurance adjusters are professionals employed by insurance companies to investigate and evaluate claims. Their primary responsibilities include: 

  • Gathering information about the claim. 
  • Assessing the extent of damages or injuries. 
  • Determining the insurance company’s liability. 
  • Negotiating settlements with claimants. 

While adjusters may present themselves as helpful intermediaries, it’s essential to remember that their ultimate goal is to minimize payouts for the insurance company. This doesn’t mean they’re dishonest, but it does mean their interests may not align with yours as the claimant. 

Adjusters employ various tactics to gather information, including: 

  • Requesting detailed statements about the incident. 
  • Seeking access to medical records and health histories. 
  • Conducting recorded interviews. 
  • Investigating your social media presence and public records. 

Understanding these tactics is the first step in protecting your interests during the claims process. 

The Risks of Sharing Your Health History     

Now that we’ve established the adjuster’s role, let’s examine why sharing your complete health history can be risky. 

Potential for Claim Devaluation 

When you provide your entire health history, you’re giving the insurance company a wealth of information that they can potentially use to reduce the value of your claim. They may argue that your current injuries or conditions are related to pre-existing issues, rather than the incident in question. 

Misuse of Pre-existing Conditions 

Insurance adjusters might use information about pre-existing conditions to suggest that your current symptoms or injuries are not entirely due to the incident covered by the claim. This tactic, known as “pre-existing condition leverage,” can significantly impact your settlement amount. 

Misinterpretation or Manipulation of Medical Information 

Without proper context, your medical history can be misinterpreted or even manipulated to suit the insurance company’s narrative. What seems like an unrelated health issue to you might be framed as a contributing factor to your current condition by a skilled adjuster. 

Privacy Concerns and Data Breaches 

In today’s digital age, data breaches are an ever-present risk. By sharing your complete health history, you’re increasing the amount of sensitive personal information that could potentially be exposed in the event of a security breach at the insurance company. 

Strategies for Protecting Your Health Information     

Here are some practical strategies for safeguarding your health information while still pursuing your claim. 

Limit the Scope of Medical Authorizations 

When an adjuster requests access to your medical records, you have the right to limit the scope of the authorization. Instead of granting blanket access to your entire health history, consider: 

  • Limiting the time frame (e.g., records from the date of the incident forward). 
  • Specifying only records related to the injuries or conditions relevant to your claim. 
  • Excluding sensitive information not pertinent to the claim. 

Provide Only Relevant Medical Records 

Work with your healthcare provider to identify and provide only the medical records directly related to your claim. This approach ensures that the adjuster has the necessary information without exposing your entire health history. 

Review Records Before Submission 

Always review your medical records before submitting them to the insurance company. This allows you to: 

  • Ensure accuracy and completeness. 
  • Identify any potentially mis-interpretable information. 
  • Prepare explanations for any complex medical issues.  

The Claims Process Without Full Health History Disclosure  

You might be wondering how to substantiate your claim without providing your full health history. Here are some alternative approaches: 

Focus on the Specific Injury or Condition 

Concentrate on providing detailed information about the injury or condition directly related to your claim. This includes: 

  • Medical records from treatments specific to the incident. 
  • Diagnostic test results related to your current condition. 
  • Expert medical opinions on the cause and extent of your injuries. 

Work with Your Healthcare Provider 

Collaborate with your doctor to obtain medical documentation that: 

  • Clearly outlines the injuries sustained in the incident. 
  • Explains the treatment plan and expected recovery time. 
  • Addresses any potential long-term effects or complications. 

Provide Objective Evidence 

Focus on presenting objective evidence that supports your claim, such as: 

  • X-rays, MRIs, or other imaging results 
  • Lab test results 
  • Physical therapy assessments and progress reports 

By taking this focused approach, you can provide the necessary information to support your claim while maintaining the privacy of your broader health history. 

Common Misconceptions About Health History Disclosure

There are several myths surrounding the disclosure of health information in insurance claims. Let’s debunk some of the most common ones: 

Myth: You Must Provide Complete Health History. 

Reality: You are not legally obligated to provide your entire health history to an insurance adjuster. You have the right to limit the information you share to what is directly relevant to your claim. 

Myth: Withholding Information Will Automatically Void Your Claim. 

Reality: While honesty is crucial in the claims process, protecting your privacy by limiting the scope of health information you share does not automatically invalidate your claim. The key is to provide all relevant information while maintaining appropriate boundaries. 

Myth: Insurance Adjusters Have Your Best Interests in Mind. 

Reality: While adjusters may be professional and courteous, their primary responsibility is to their employer – the insurance company. Their goal is to settle claims in a way that benefits the company, which may not always align with your best interests.  

The Impact of Health History on Claim Valuation 

Understanding how adjusters use health information to calculate settlements can help you protect the true value of your claim: 

How Adjusters Use Health Information 

  • To identify pre-existing conditions that might reduce claim value. 
  • To assess the long-term impact of new injuries. 
  • To determine the necessity and reasonableness of medical treatments. 

Protecting Your Claim’s Value 

  • Provide clear documentation linking your current condition to the incident. 
  • Obtain expert medical opinions on the impact of the injury. 
  • Be prepared to explain how the current injury differs from or exacerbates any pre-existing conditions. 

Negotiation Strategies 

  • Focus discussions on the specific injuries related to the claim. 
  • Highlight the impact of the injury on your daily life and ability to work. 
  • Be prepared to counter arguments about pre-existing conditions with medical evidence. 

Strong Legal Guidance from Our Skilled Alabama Personal Injury Firm 

Navigating insurance claims while protecting your personal health information can be challenging. By understanding your legal rights under HIPAA and strategically disclosing information, you can protect your interests and pursue a fair settlement while maintaining your privacy.   

When dealing with complex insurance claims, having experienced legal representation can make all the difference. Contact the Law Office of J. Allan Brown L.L.C. today for a free and confidential consultation to discuss your case and ensure that you fully understand your legal rights. 

J. Allan Brown, LLC
Law Office of J. Allan Brown, LLC, is located in Mobile, AL and serves clients in and around Mobile, Bucks, Satsuma, Eight Mile, Semmes, Spanish Fort, Citronelle, Theodore, Saraland, Montrose, Irvington, Saint Elmo, Wilmer, Point Clear, Grand Bay, Chunchula, Fairhope, Creola, Bayou La Batre, Axis, Coden, Bay Minette, Silverhill, Baldwin County and Mobile County.
Sundown Marketing

© 2014 - 2025 Law Office of J. Allan Brown, LLC. All rights reserved.
This is a Sundown Legal Marketing law firm website.

Contact Form Tab